AI
Edward Ilin9 min read
Your client just read the Coca-Cola story. They will ask about your workflow next.
They may ask in a call, or in a one-line email. Either way, you want an answer ready.
Coca-Cola replaced its generative-AI holiday commercials with human-directed "Enjoy Joy" spots. For agency content leads, the shift signals that audiences judge AI use by emotional context, and the risk sits in one type of asset that is easy to spot.
Here is how to build that answer this week.
A familiar brand's AI-produced Christmas commercial was called "AI slop" in public. Per Marketing Dive, Coca-Cola is returning to a traditional approach with its "Enjoy Joy" spots. The ads were directed by Paul Dektor and produced by Mayan Productions. They follow two years of holiday ads made with generative AI. Those ads beat the brand's internal benchmarks but still proved divisive with consumers.
The numbers inside the company looked fine. The public reaction did not. Search coverage from this week shows the tone: a Google News result summarizes one reaction as the internet calling the brand's commercial "AI slop." When that label sticks, the conversation stops being about the ad. It becomes about whether the brand has good judgment.
Marketing Dive also notes that Coca-Cola arrives here as holiday marketers double down on human-made creative. The category is moving, and your clients' competitors may move with it.
Clients will want to know whether your AI-assisted work could trigger the same reaction, and the data explains why. An IAB study reported by MarketingProfs found that 82% of ad executives believe Gen Z and millennial consumers feel positive about AI ads, while only 45% of those consumers do. That is a wide gap between what the industry assumes and what audiences feel.
Disclosure and trust tell a similar story. A Cint report with Advertising Week found that 74% of respondents believe brands and creators have a duty to disclose AI use in advertising, and 44% say discovering non-disclosure would decrease their trust in the brand. A Talker Research survey commissioned by Auros found that 43% of Americans have felt duped by AI ads, and 36% believe a product is lower quality if AI is used in its marketing.
Together, these findings make the client conversation predictable. Your client's brand takes the reputational hit, not yours. They need to know you have a process. A stretched content lead without one is left improvising on a call.
The risk scales with emotional stakes, not with the tool. Coca-Cola's holiday spot is not a product shot. Marketing Dive quotes Stacy Jackson, vice president for the Coca-Cola Trademark, saying people look forward to seeing how the brand shows up each year.
That anticipation is the asset. When viewers expect warmth and tradition, an AI-made version can read as a shortcut, even if it tested well internally.
The new campaign confirms where the brand put its human effort. Its "Grandma's Holiday Table" social series focuses on the "abuelas, nonnas, nanas, aunties and tÃas" who carry holiday traditions. These are the people who keep those traditions alive.
Those are people-first stories, and the brand told them with people.
Using AI to resize assets, draft caption options or build first-pass outlines carries little of this exposure. Using it for the one piece your client's audience waits for every year carries a lot. Don't tell a client "never use AI." Tell them where it is safe and where a human has to own the craft.
This is one campaign's change of direction, not a reported exit from AI.
A tool like Brainpercent can help, since keeping drafts, brand voice and approvals in one workflow makes the audit and the sign-off trail easier to maintain.
Bring a short list instead of a defense.
Start by separating the evidence from the headline. One brand moved one flagship asset back to human hands, and you are applying the same logic to their account.
Name two or three deliverables where AI saves real time without audience risk, such as caption variants, format resizes and first-pass outlines. Then name the one or two assets where a person leads the craft.
A client who sees you already drew that line will usually relax. A client who hears "we use AI everywhere, it's fine" will not.
It can hit anyone, but the trigger is smaller than people assume. Coverage of the Coca-Cola ad shows the pattern: one summary framed it as a familiar brand stumbling when it stepped into new territory. Familiarity is what raised the stakes. People had a picture in their heads of what the brand's holiday spot should feel like, and the AI version didn't match it.
A regional retailer with a loyal local following, or a family-run brand with a founder story, has the same exposure on a smaller stage. A pile-on of a few hundred comments can feel just as heavy to a small client as a viral moment does to a giant. Ask yourself which of your client's assets people recognize and wait for. Those are your watch list, whatever the client's size.
Keep it plain and specific. Something like: "AI tools were used for [named task] on [named deliverable]; a human reviewed and approved the final version." Name the task, not just the tool. "Used for drafting three caption options" tells the client far more than "AI-assisted."
One practical habit: write the line when you scope the work, not after delivery. If a high-stakes asset turns up with no disclosure line because nobody planned for one, that is your signal to stop and talk to the client before launch. It is a much easier chat on a Tuesday afternoon than in the middle of a comment pile-on.
Take the numbers seriously, then ask what they measured.
Internal benchmarks usually track things like recall, view-through or favorability among a sampled group. They rarely capture how a loud minority talks about the work in public, or what that talk does to the brand's reputation.
Coca-Cola's own case, per search coverage, shows how a commercial can be read as ruining a holiday tradition even while the dashboard looks healthy.
Suggest adding one line to your reporting for AI-touched flagship work: a short social listening check in the first 48 hours after launch. Track the tone of comments and shares, not only the reach, so the client can watch the risk without arguing about taste. If the tone sours, your one-page response plan is already waiting.
Do it per client, in thirty minutes each, and only for the next ninety days of planned work. Open the content calendar and circle anything seasonal, anything tied to an anniversary or founder story, and anything the client's audience asks about every year. Ignore the rest for now. Those circled items are your high-stakes list, and most clients will have fewer than five.
For each circled item, write one sentence: who leads the craft, and where AI is allowed to help. Then send the list to the client as a single email asking for a yes or a change. You now have a documented decision for every risky asset, and the everyday work keeps moving at the speed it already does.
Audiences judge AI by emotional context, not by the tool. Resizes, caption options and first-pass drafts carry little exposure, while the one asset your client's audience waits for every year carries a lot.
You do not need a policy overhaul to be ready for that call. Open your current deliverables list today and mark every high-stakes item for human-led craft. If keeping drafts, brand voice and approvals in one place would make that audit easier, see it in action with Brainpercent and test it on one client's next content batch.
Ready to automate all this? Brainpercent is the all-in-one content platform that generates SEO articles, social posts, and videos for you, on autopilot. Start your free trial or see pricing.
Posts, images and videos from your own site, in minutes.
Try it free